I remember after my son was born, I Googled: “Is it normal to not feel the same about your second kid as your first?”
When my daughter was born, the feelings of love and connection were overwhelming. It felt easy.
With my son, two and a half years later, I felt disconnected. The love was there, but the intensity I had felt with my daughter was missing. Then came the guilt. I felt like I was failing both of my kids.
It took me — a mental health professional — over a year to realize I was experiencing postpartum depression. Eventually, I got on medication and found an amazing therapist. My bond with my son formed quickly, and now we are closer than ever.
The Lindsay Clancy trial has brought a lot of those memories back. I have had to be careful about how much I read, but it has been hard to avoid because it keeps coming up in therapist conversations.
I do not know all the details of that case. But I do know this: our systems continue to fail postpartum moms every single day. My story could have gone differently if I had not been a therapist myself.
And I also know that many therapists are watching this case and feeling scared.
Scared about their notes.
Scared about court.
Scared about whether they documented enough.
Scared about whether they documented too much.
Scared that one day, something they wrote in a therapy note could be read out loud by someone whose job is to tear it apart.
So let’s talk about it.
Not from a place of panic. Not from a place of fear-based documentation. But from a place of ethical, thoughtful clinical care.
Disclaimer: This post is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. Documentation laws and standards vary by state, license, setting, employer, payer, and clinical situation. When in doubt, consult your supervisor, attorney, malpractice carrier, licensing board, or professional ethics board.
First: A Lawyer’s Job Is Not the Same as Your Job
One thing I want therapists to remember is this:
If your notes ever end up in court, a lawyer’s job may be to pull them apart.
That does not automatically mean you wrote bad notes.
It means the legal system and the therapy room operate very differently.
Therapists are trained to think clinically, relationally, ethically, and systemically. Attorneys are trained to advocate for their side. Those two roles can collide in uncomfortable ways.
That is why the goal is not to write “court-proof” notes. I am not sure those exist.
The goal is to write clinically appropriate notes that:
- Support continuity of care
- Document your clinical reasoning
- Reflect safety concerns when relevant
- Protect your client’s privacy
- Meet the standards of your setting
- Show that you acted thoughtfully and ethically
Good notes are not perfect notes. Good notes are useful, clear, and clinically grounded.
1. Remember: Good Notes Are Not “Perfect” Notes
A lot of therapists hear stories about court and immediately think, “I need to write everything down.”
But more detail is not always better.
Therapy notes are not transcripts. They are clinical records.
A good therapy note generally documents:
- What brought the client to care
- What clinical themes were addressed
- What interventions were used
- How the client responded
- Any relevant risk or safety concerns
- The plan for follow-up
- Referrals, consultation, or supervision when clinically indicated
The note does not need to capture every word, every detail, or every emotionally intense moment.
In fact, over-documenting can create its own problems. It may expose more of the client’s private life than is clinically necessary.
The better question is:
“What needs to be in this record to support treatment, safety, diagnosis, billing, ethical care, and continuity?”
If it does not serve one of those purposes, it may not need to be there.
2. Document According to Your Setting
Documentation standards are not one-size-fits-all.
A therapist working in a hospital may have different requirements than someone in private practice. A school-based therapist, agency clinician, community mental health provider, group practice therapist, or insurance-based provider may all have different documentation expectations.
So instead of asking, “What is the perfect note?” ask:
“What does my setting require, and what does this clinical situation require?”
If you work in an agency, school, hospital, or group practice, know your organization’s policies.
If you are in private practice, create clear documentation policies for yourself. Make sure they are aligned with your license, state law, payer requirements, ethics code, and clinical population.
Your notes should fit your actual work.
3. Document Safety Clearly
If safety is part of the clinical picture, your note should show that you assessed it.
This does not mean every note needs a long risk assessment. But when safety is relevant, your documentation should reflect your clinical thinking.
Safety documentation may include:
- Suicidal ideation
- Homicidal ideation
- Self-harm
- Domestic violence
- Abuse or neglect concerns
- Substance use concerns
- Access to means
- Protective factors
- Safety planning
- Crisis resources provided
- Higher level of care considered or recommended
- Mandated report made, if applicable
- Consultation or supervision obtained
4. Keep Supervision and Consultation in the Process
If you are worried about a case, do not hold that worry alone.
Consultation and supervision are not signs that you are doing something wrong. They are part of ethical clinical practice.
Consult when cases involve:
- Suicidality
- Homicidality
- Postpartum mental health concerns
- Psychosis
- Abuse or neglect
- Domestic violence
- Custody conflict
- Court involvement
- Subpoenas
- High-conflict relationships
- Requests for letters
- Unclear boundaries
- Mandated reporting concerns
Depending on the situation, consultation might include a supervisor, trusted colleague, attorney, ethics board, licensing board, or malpractice carrier.
And when clinically appropriate, document the consultation.
That does not mean you need to write a transcript of the conversation. You might simply document:
“Consulted with clinical supervisor regarding risk assessment and treatment planning. Plan: continue safety monitoring, review crisis plan, and provide referral options as clinically indicated.”
This shows you were thoughtful, not isolated.
5. Protect Your Client’s Privacy
This is one of the biggest points I want therapists to understand:
Therapy records are not journals.
They are not a place to write down every intimate detail a client shares.
You can often document sensitive material at a higher clinical level while still preserving the meaning.
Instead of writing highly specific trauma details, you might write:
“Client processed history of trauma and its current impact on mood, relationships, and sense of safety.”
Instead of writing every detail of a marital conflict, you might write:
“Client explored relational stressors and patterns of conflict contributing to anxiety symptoms.”
Of course, sometimes details matter. Details may be clinically necessary for safety, mandated reporting, treatment planning, diagnosis, coordination of care, or legal/ethical reasons.
But before writing something deeply private, pause and ask:
“Does this detail need to live in the clinical record?”
If the answer is no, consider leaving it out.
6. Use Neutral, Behavioral Language
Court anxiety often gets worse when notes are full of vague, emotional, or judgmental language.
Instead of:
“Client was manipulative and dramatic.”
Try:
“Client became tearful, raised voice, and expressed concern that they were not being heard.”
Instead of:
“Client is noncompliant.”
Try:
“Client did not complete between-session practice and reported ambivalence about treatment goals.”
Instead of:
“Client’s ex is narcissistic and abusive.”
Try:
“Client reported feeling fearful in interactions with former partner and described concerns about controlling behavior.”
Neutral language is more clinically useful. It also protects the client, the therapist, and the integrity of the record.
7. Be Careful About Diagnosing People Who Are Not Your Client
This comes up often in individual therapy, couples work, family therapy, custody cases, and high-conflict relationships.
A client may say:
- “My ex is a narcissist.”
- “My partner is abusive.”
- “My parent has borderline personality disorder.”
- “My spouse is manipulating everyone.”
You can document what the client reports without making it your own clinical conclusion.
For example:
“Client reported concerns about former partner’s behavior and described feeling unsafe during recent interactions.”
That is different from writing:
“Client’s former partner is abusive and narcissistic.”
Unless you have evaluated that person directly and are operating in an appropriate clinical or forensic role, be cautious about diagnosing or characterizing non-clients.
8. Know the Difference Between Treatment and Forensic Roles
A lot of problems happen when therapists get pulled out of the therapy role and into a legal role without realizing it.
A client may ask:
- “Can you write a letter saying I should have custody?”
- “Can you tell the court my ex is unsafe?”
- “Can you say I am a good parent?”
- “Can you write that I cannot work?”
- “Can you confirm that what I said happened?”
These requests may seem simple. But they can quickly become forensic.
A treating therapist’s role is not the same as a custody evaluator, disability evaluator, expert witness, or investigator.
Before writing letters or making recommendations, ask:
- Am I qualified to answer this question?
- Is this within my role?
- Have I evaluated all relevant parties?
- Am I being asked for a legal opinion?
- Could this harm the client or therapy relationship?
- Do I need consultation before responding?
It is okay to say:
“My role is as your treating therapist, not as a forensic evaluator.”
That clarity protects everyone.
9. Be Cautious With Letters and Summaries
Therapists often get asked to write letters.
Some letters are straightforward:
- Attendance confirmation
- Dates of treatment
- General treatment focus
- Diagnosis, when appropriate and authorized
- Referral needs
- Accommodation support within scope
Other letters are more complicated:
- Custody recommendations
- Statements about parenting fitness
- Opinions about someone you have not evaluated
- Legal conclusions
- Claims about truthfulness
- Disability determinations outside your expertise
If you write a letter, stay factual, neutral, and within your scope.
You can say what you know clinically. Be careful about saying more than that.
10. Do Not Ignore a Subpoena — But Do Not Automatically Send Records
This is important.
If you receive a subpoena, do not ignore it.
But also do not panic and immediately send the entire record.
A subpoena is not always the same as a court order. Rules vary by state and situation. There may be ways to object, limit, redact, request client consent, or ask that records be sealed.
A general response might include:
- Pause before releasing anything
- Review the request carefully
- Contact your malpractice carrier
- Consult an attorney if needed
- Review state law and ethics requirements
- Notify the client when appropriate and legally allowed
- Determine whether the request is valid
- Determine whether disclosure can be limited
- Document your decision-making process
The goal is to protect client confidentiality as much as the law allows.
11. Understand Privacy, Confidentiality, and Privilege
Therapists often use these words interchangeably, but they are not exactly the same.
Privacy refers broadly to a client’s right to control personal information.
Confidentiality refers to your ethical and legal duty to protect client information.
Privilege is a legal protection that may allow certain therapy communications to be protected from disclosure in court.
Privilege varies by state and circumstance. It may also be waived or limited.
This is one reason therapists should not handle court-related requests casually. When legal questions come up, consult.
12. Separate Psychotherapy Notes From the Clinical Record When Appropriate
Some therapists keep psychotherapy or process notes separate from the official clinical record.
This can be appropriate in some settings, but it needs to be done correctly.
HIPAA has specific rules about psychotherapy notes, and state laws may vary. Therapists should understand what counts as part of the designated record set, what may be requested, and what protections apply.
If you keep separate process notes, make sure you know:
- Where they are stored
- Whether they are truly separate
- Whether they can be requested
- How your state treats them
- How your informed consent explains them
- Whether your setting allows them
Do not assume that calling something a “process note” automatically protects it.
13. Have Policies Before You Need Them
Private practice therapists especially need policies around court involvement and records.
Ideally, your informed consent should address:
- Record requests
- Subpoenas
- Court testimony
- Fees for legal involvement
- Communication with attorneys
- Letters and forms
- Custody-related requests
- Releases of information
- Documentation timelines
- Record retention
- Limits of confidentiality
It is much easier to explain your boundaries before a crisis than after a subpoena arrives.
If you do not have these policies yet, this is a good time to review them.
14. Do Not Let Fear Make Your Notes Less Useful
Some therapists respond to court anxiety by documenting everything.
Others respond by documenting almost nothing.
Neither extreme is ideal.
Over-documenting can expose unnecessary private information. Under-documenting can make it difficult to show your clinical reasoning, risk assessment, treatment planning, and continuity of care.
The goal is thoughtful documentation.
A helpful mantra:
Document what matters. Leave out what does not. Consult when unsure.
Your notes should support the work, not replace the work.
What ACA, APA, and NASW Ethics Emphasize
Across professional ethics codes and guidance, a few themes consistently show up:
- Protect client confidentiality
- Disclose only what is necessary
- Understand legal and ethical requirements
- Seek consultation when needed
- Maintain appropriate records
- Take steps to limit disclosure in legal proceedings when possible
- Practice within your role and scope
The ACA Code of Ethics says that when counselors are ordered by a court to release confidential or privileged information without client permission, they should seek written informed consent from the client or take steps to prohibit or limit disclosure as narrowly as possible because of potential harm to the client or counseling relationship.
NASW similarly emphasizes protecting client confidentiality during legal proceedings to the extent permitted by law and requesting that courts withdraw, narrow, or seal orders when disclosure could harm the client.
APA record-keeping guidance also emphasizes that records should document treatment plans, services provided, and client progress while taking legal requirements, ethical standards, and practice needs into account.
The common thread is not fear.
The common thread is thoughtful, ethical care.
A Simple Documentation Checklist for Therapists
Before signing a note, ask yourself:
- Did I document according to my setting’s requirements?
- Did I include the clinically relevant themes?
- Did I document interventions used?
- Did I document client response or progress?
- Did I document safety concerns when relevant?
- Did I include consultation or supervision when needed?
- Did I avoid unnecessary intimate details?
- Did I use neutral, behavioral language?
- Did I avoid diagnosing people who are not my client?
- Did I stay within my clinical role?
- Did I document the plan?
This does not have to make notes longer. It can actually make them clearer.
Final Thought: Documentation Is Part of Care
I understand why therapists are scared right now.
When we see therapy notes discussed in court, it can make us feel exposed. It can make us question every word we have ever written.
But fear is not a good documentation strategy.
Ethical documentation is not about protecting yourself at the expense of the client. It is about protecting the client, the work, and the integrity of the clinical relationship.
You are not trying to write perfect notes.
You are trying to write notes that are clinically appropriate, ethically sound, privacy-conscious, and clear enough to show your reasoning.
That is the work.
And if you are unsure, consult. You do not have to figure it out alone!


